Benny's Brick Oven Pizza

Dairy brick oven pizza in Brooklyn with seating and delivery

✡ K'hal Chizuk Hadas of Flatbush

Location: New York, New York

Organizer: Benny's Brick Oven Pizza

About

Benny's Brick Oven Pizza is a kosher establishment serving Dairy food in Brooklyn, under K'hal Chizuk Hadas of Flatbush supervision.

Features:

Dine-in
Takeout
Delivery
Good for children
Good for groups
Wheelchair accessible
Serves coffee

Price level: Mid-range

Activities & entertainment

Monday: 11:00 AM – 8:30 PM
Tuesday: 11:00 AM – 8:30 PM
Wednesday: 11:00 AM – 8:30 PM
Thursday: 11:00 AM – 8:30 PM
Friday: 11:00 AM – 8:30 PM
Saturday: Closed
Sunday: 11:00 AM – 8:30 PM

Location

Address: 1802 Avenue M, Brooklyn, NY 11230, USA

Tags

Food services

Contact

Organizer: Benny's Brick Oven Pizza
Location: New York
Phone: +1-(718) 787-0050
Website: https://order.toasttab.com/online/bennysbrickovenavenuem

Explore More

About this listing

Benny's Brick Oven Pizza stands as a staple in the heart of the Midwood neighborhood of Brooklyn. This dairy establishment has earned a reputation for providing a reliable and inviting dining experience for the local Jewish community and visitors alike. By combining traditional brick oven techniques with a strictly kosher kitchen, the restaurant offers a menu that bridges the gap between classic Italian-style preparation and community standards.

Operating under the supervision of K'hal Chizuk Hadas of Flatbush, the restaurant ensures that all ingredients and preparation methods meet rigorous kashrut requirements. The focus here is on quality dairy and pareve offerings, ranging from thin-crust pizzas to a variety of pastas and fresh salads. Whether you are stopping in for a quick lunch or planning a family dinner, the atmosphere is designed to be welcoming and efficient.

The establishment is more than just a local pizzeria; it is a gathering place within a bustling corridor of Jewish life. With a commitment to consistent service, it caters to the diverse needs of the neighborhood by offering dine-in, takeout, and delivery services. The inclusion of coffee service and a mid-range price point makes it an accessible option for daily meals or special community gatherings.

About the area

Situated at 1802 Avenue M, the restaurant is located in one of Brooklyn's most vibrant and established Jewish enclaves. Midwood—and specifically the Avenue M strip—is famous for its concentration of kosher eateries, grocery stores, and religious institutions. The location is easily accessible via public transportation, with the Avenue M subway station serving the Q train just a short walk away, providing a direct link to both South Brooklyn and Manhattan.

The neighborhood is characterized by its residential stability and its role as a center for Orthodox Jewish life. Avenue M serves as a primary commercial artery where residents can find everything from specialized kosher butchers to boutique clothing stores. Being located in this district means the restaurant is integrated into the daily rhythm of the community, where the sidewalk is often busy with local shoppers and students from nearby yeshivas.

Parking in the area is typical for a busy Brooklyn thoroughfare, with metered street parking available on Avenue M and side-street options in the surrounding residential blocks. The proximity to other major roads like Ocean Avenue and Coney Island Avenue makes it a convenient destination for those driving from neighboring areas such as Marine Park, Bensonhurst, or Kensington.

Nearby Jewish landmarks

The Avenue M corridor is a central hub for Brooklyn’s Jewish community, offering a high density of services and landmarks within a few blocks. Notable nearby institutions include the Young Israel of Avenue J and Agudath Israel of Madison, both of which serve as major spiritual anchors for the local population. These long-standing synagogues contribute to the steady flow of foot traffic in the neighborhood throughout the day and evening.

Those seeking more than just a meal will find the area rich in Jewish resources. Eichler’s, a world-renowned Judaica store, is located just a short distance away, drawing visitors from across the Tri-State area for books, gifts, and religious items. The vicinity also features several established mikvahs and is firmly positioned within the Flatbush eruv, making it a convenient stop for families and residents adhering to traditional observances.

Greening the urban landscape, Ocean Parkway is only a few blocks to the west. This historic thoroughfare features a wide pedestrian and bike path that is popular for afternoon walks. The surrounding residential streets are known for their quiet, community-oriented atmosphere, punctuated by various small yeshivas and community centers that have defined the Midwood identity for generations.

What to expect

Visitors to Benny's Brick Oven Pizza can expect a functional and clean environment tailored for both quick bites and sit-down meals. The interior is designed to accommodate different group sizes, featuring seating that works well for families with children or larger communal groups. The centerpiece of the kitchen is the brick oven, which produces a distinct crust texture that differentiates their offerings from standard New York-style slices.

The menu emphasizes dairy (Cholov Yisroel) staples. Customers often choose from a variety of specialty pizzas, where the high heat of the brick oven creates a charred, crisp finish. Beyond pizza, the kitchen prepares a selection of hot dishes including eggplant parmigiana, baked ziti, and various pasta specialties. For those looking for lighter options, the salad menu provides fresh pareve and dairy choices that are prepared to order.

Service is professional and geared toward the local pace of life. During peak hours, such as Sunday evenings or post-Sabbath periods, the restaurant can become quite busy with local families. The staff is accustomed to managing high volumes of both in-house diners and delivery orders. Additionally, the facility is wheelchair accessible, ensuring that all members of the community can dine comfortably. For those seeking a caffeine fix, the restaurant also serves coffee, making it a suitable spot for a casual meeting or a mid-afternoon break.

Frequently asked questions

What is the kosher supervision at Benny's Brick Oven Pizza?

This establishment is under the kosher supervision of K'hal Chizuk Hadas of Flatbush. This is a local certification recognized within the Brooklyn community.

Is the food dairy or meat?

Yes, the menu is strictly dairy (Cholov Yisroel), focusing on artisanal pizzas, pastas, and other Mediterranean-inspired dairy dishes.

Do they offer delivery or takeout?

Yes, the restaurant provides delivery services throughout the local Midwood and Flatbush areas, as well as takeout options for those on the move.

Is the location suitable for families and large groups?

Benny's is known for being family-friendly with a casual atmosphere that accommodates groups, children, and those requiring wheelchair access.

Where exactly is the restaurant located?

The restaurant is situated on Avenue M near the corner of East 18th Street in the Midwood section of Brooklyn.