Upper Crust Brick oven pizza and pasta in Cedarhurst and Queens.
✡ Vaad of the Five Towns and Far Rockaway Location: Village of Cedarhurst, New York
Organizer: Upper Crust
About Opened in September 2019, the pizza restaurant Upper Crust opened a second branch in Queens. The original shop is in Cedarhurst. Brick oven pizza options are endless: alla vodka, spicy chiptole, merguez, fajita, caprese, melanzana, Jerusalem, margherita, pepperoni, to name a few. On the pasta menu are zucchini spirals, pappardelle, gnocchi, penne alla vodka, fettuccine […]
Features:
Dine-in Takeout Delivery Reservations available Good for children Good for groups Wheelchair accessible Serves coffee Serves dessert Price level: Mid-range
Activities & entertainment Monday: 11:00 AM – 8:00 PMLocation Address: 442 Central Ave, Cedarhurst, NY 11516, USA
Home · Contact · List your business About this listing Upper Crust is a dedicated dairy establishment located in the heart of Cedarhurst, New York. Since its opening in late 2019, the restaurant has become a local staple for those seeking high-quality Italian cuisine prepared in a traditional brick oven. Situated on the bustling Central Avenue, it caters to both the local Five Towns community and visitors looking for a sophisticated yet family-friendly dining experience.
The restaurant specializes in a wide array of artisanal pizzas and classic pasta dishes. With a focus on fresh ingredients and diverse flavor profiles, the menu spans from traditional Italian staples to more contemporary Mediterranean-inspired creations. Whether you are looking for a quick lunch or a sit-down dinner with a group, the atmosphere is designed to accommodate various dining needs within a strictly kosher environment.
As a key player in the vibrant Five Towns kosher food scene, this location represents the original branch of the brand. Its presence on one of the most recognizable streets in the Jewish community makes it an easy destination for anyone navigating Nassau County's South Shore neighborhoods.
About the area Located at 442 Central Avenue, the restaurant sits in one of the most densely populated Jewish corridors in the United States. Cedarhurst is a central part of the "Five Towns" area in Nassau County, known for its extensive Jewish infrastructure and high concentration of kosher-certified businesses. The storefront is easily accessible and surrounded by a variety of retail shops and professional services.
The geographic location is highly convenient for residents of neighboring towns like Far Rockaway, Lawrence, and Woodmere. Central Avenue itself is the main artery for the community, providing a walkable environment where diners can run errands or visit nearby Jewish landmarks before or after a meal. Public transport options, including the Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) Far Rockaway Branch, are within reasonable proximity, connecting the area to Queens and Manhattan.
Being situated in the Village of Cedarhurst means the restaurant operates within an environment that understands and respects the needs of the Sabbath-observant community. The local streetscape is characterized by its quiet atmosphere on Saturdays and its high energy during the week, particularly on Sundays and Jewish holidays.
Nearby Jewish landmarks The Village of Cedarhurst serves as a primary commercial hub for the surrounding Jewish neighborhoods, including Woodmere, Lawrence, and Hewlett. Visitors will find themselves within walking distance of numerous judaica shops, modest clothing boutiques, and Jewish bookstores that line Central Avenue.
For those attending services, the area is home to several prominent shuls, such as Kehillas Bais Yehuda Tzvi (the Red Shul) and the Young Israel of Cedarhurst. The local eruv is well-established, covering the residential streets that surround the business district, making the area particularly active on Friday afternoons and Motza'ei Shabbat.
Beyond the immediate culinary options, the Five Towns community offers comprehensive infrastructure for the observant traveler. This includes several large kosher supermarkets, multiple mikvaot, and a variety of batei midrash that host daily minyanim from sunrise until late at night.
What to expect Guests can expect a warm and inviting atmosphere characterized by the aroma of fresh dough baking in a brick oven. The interior is designed to be comfortable for many types of diners, offering a mid-range price point that balances quality with accessibility. The seating arrangements are suitable for groups, making it a common choice for family celebrations or casual meetups with friends.
The pizza selection is a primary draw, featuring a range of creative toppings. You will find options such as the Jerusalem pizza, alla vodka, and caprese, alongside unique spicy and savory combinations like merguez or chipotle-inspired pies. The use of a brick oven ensures a specific texture and char that is traditional to high-end pizzerias.
Pasta enthusiasts will find a comprehensive menu including penne alla vodka, fettuccine, and zucchini spirals for those seeking lighter fare. The inclusion of gnocchi and pappardelle highlights the kitchen's commitment to varied Italian textures. To complete the meal, the establishment serves coffee and a selection of desserts, providing a full-course dining experience for those with the time to linger.
Service at this location includes dine-in, takeout, and delivery, ensuring flexibility for busy families or local workers. Reservations are also available, which is often recommended during peak evening hours or on Sundays when the Central Avenue area sees an influx of visitors.
Frequently asked questions Which kosher certification does Upper Crust hold? Upper Crust is under the rabbinical supervision of the Vaad of the Five Towns and Far Rockaway.
Is the menu dairy or meat? The menu is focused on dairy (Cholov Yisroel) and pareve Italian-style cuisine, including various cheeses and plant-based toppings.
Does this location offer delivery to the local area? Yes, this establishment offers both takeout and delivery services for its full menu of pizzas and pastas.
Is the restaurant family-friendly? Yes, the restaurant is described as being good for children and groups, with wheelchair-accessible facilities.
What types of food are served at this location? The menu features a diverse range of brick oven pizzas, various pasta dishes including gnocchi and pappardelle, coffee, and desserts.