Gotta Getta Bagel Fresh bagels and coffee with Vaad Five Towns certification.
✡ Vaad of the Five Towns and Far Rockaway Location: Woodmere, New York
Organizer: Gotta Getta Bagel
About UPDATE, 3/11/25 PM I just received an update from Rabbi Schechter that the business has recommitted to keeping their kashrut standards, and the rabbi has agreed to reinstate their hechsher. The rabbi credits the YeahThatsKosher article, published less than 8 hours ago, in pressuring the business to keep up the standards for their kosher certification. […]
Features:
Dine-in Takeout Delivery Wheelchair accessible Serves coffee Price level: Mid-range
Activities & entertainment Monday: 6:00 AM – 4:00 PMLocation Address: 1039 Broadway, Woodmere, NY 11598, USA
Tags Bakery/ Café Take Away Food services
Home · Contact · List your business About this listing Gotta Getta Bagel is a prominent kosher bagel shop and bakery located on the busy Broadway corridor in Woodmere, New York. Situated in the heart of the Five Towns, this establishment has long served as a local destination for fresh-baked goods, breakfast items, and coffee. The shop caters to the significant observant Jewish population in the area, providing a reliable space for morning meals and afternoon snacks.
Following a brief period of uncertainty regarding its kashrut status in early 2024, the business recommitted to maintaining strict standards. This dedication resulted in the reinstatement of its formal certification, ensuring that the local community can continue to patronize the establishment with confidence. The shop remains a staple of the Woodmere food scene, known for its traditional preparation methods and central location.
As a mid-range food service provider, the business balances quality with accessibility. Whether you are seeking a quick morning coffee or a full breakfast spread for the family, the establishment offers a variety of dairy-based options that reflect the classic New York bagel tradition.
About the area The address at 1039 Broadway places the business in a prime location within Woodmere, one of the primary hamlets comprising the Five Towns on Long Island’s South Shore. This region is renowned for its high concentration of Jewish residents and extensive communal infrastructure. Broadway serves as the main thoroughfare for the area, connecting Woodmere to neighboring Cedarhurst, Hewlett, and Lawrence.
Living and visiting the Five Towns means having immediate access to a wide array of kosher services. The shop is positioned among a dense network of Jewish institutions, making it a frequent stop for those running errands or heading to morning prayers (Shacharit) at any of the numerous nearby shuls. Its proximity to the Woodmere train station also makes it a popular choice for daily commuters heading into the city.
Nearby Jewish landmarks Woodmere and the surrounding Five Towns represent one of the most vibrant centers of Jewish life in North America. Within walking distance of the shop, visitors can find numerous established synagogues, including Young Israel of Woodmere and Congregation Aish Kodesh, which serve as spiritual anchors for the local community.
The Broadway corridor is a dedicated hub for kosher commerce, featuring various supermarkets, Judaica stores, and specialty shops that cater to the observant lifestyle. For those visiting from out of town, the area is well-equipped with local mikvahs and is entirely enclosed within the Five Towns Eruv.
Beyond the immediate dining options, the neighborhood is known for its proximity to several parks and the Long Island Rail Road, making it a convenient stop for commuters traveling between the South Shore and Manhattan.
What to expect Visitors to this Woodmere storefront can expect a classic bagel shop atmosphere characterized by efficient service and a clean, accessible environment. The interior is designed to accommodate various needs, featuring seating for those who prefer to dine-in and a streamlined counter for quick takeout orders. The facility is fully wheelchair accessible, ensuring a welcoming experience for all patrons.
The menu focuses on dairy and parve offerings, consistent with the requirements of the Vaad of the Five Towns. Freshly boiled and baked bagels are the centerpiece, complemented by a selection of spreads, sandwiches, and premium coffee. Each item is prepared according to the kashrut guidelines overseen by the local rabbinate.
Service is organized to handle the morning rush typical of the Five Towns, with options for delivery available for those who cannot visit in person. The pricing remains within the mid-range category, offering value for residents and visitors seeking a high-quality kosher breakfast or lunch in a neighborhood where kashrut standards are a top priority.
Frequently asked questions Where is Gotta Getta Bagel located? Gotta Getta Bagel is located at 1039 Broadway, Woodmere, NY 11598. It is situated in the heart of the Five Towns Jewish community.
What is the kosher certification for this business? The establishment is certified kosher by the Vaad of the Five Towns and Far Rockaway. This certification covers their bagels, coffee, and other prepared food offerings.
Do they offer delivery or takeout? Yes, the shop offers both delivery and takeout services, in addition to providing a space for customers to dine-in.
Is the location wheelchair accessible? The shop is wheelchair accessible, ensuring that all members of the community can visit comfortably.
What kind of food does Gotta Getta Bagel serve? The menu is categorized as dairy (milky) and includes fresh bagels, specialty coffees, and various bakery items.
